Scallywags Grub & Spirits

Wonderful theme and food, fair wings

Omg a pirate theme! Very charming and fun atmosphere. The other food we tried on the menu was a 5/5. However, this place is kinda located in the middle of nowhere in Lake Shore and does not quite have a representative Buffalo feel. Additionally, there was no celery, only carrot sticks. Bleu cheese was watery and slightly sweet. It might be homemade, which would explain why it deviates from the norm. All of these things are not necessarily negative aspects, but we had to shave off a few points.

Overall a decent wing, but inconsistent sizes, non-traditional sweetness in the sauce, and surprisingly gummy texture did not make this wing shine.

Slightly sweet and some sort of extra flavor that deviated from a traditional Buffalo sauce. Heat level was lip-smackingly good.

Outside skin was perfectly crispy but the inner meat was somewhat gummy. We think the inconsistent sizes of the wings were to blame for this.

Size and quality were a problem. 6 flats, 4 drums. Wildly different sizes. Some of the drums were so big that they were a bit difficult to eat. Some of the wings were not cooked uniformly due to extreme variance in size.

Have you eaten at Scallywags Grub & Spirits? Share your own experience in the comments below.