Mammoser's Tavern

These wings taste like acid reflux

Final Overall Score: 1.5 

Restaurant: 3.5 

• Old, wood panels, run down, dark. Buffalo “charm.” Located in Hamburg, which is a bit of a hike from downtown, especially if you’re just visiting Buffalo. Not the most ideal location to bring guests.

Taste: 0.5 

• Just not good. Dry, rubbery, no sauce, extremely spicy rub on the outside. If acid reflux took the form of a chicken wing, this would be it. Not at all a traditional Buffalo wing, and not even a good wing. At least there was celery and bleu cheese included.

Sauce: 0.0

• More of a rub than a sauce. Not a standard heat, but an alarming, aggressive spiciness. Made the wings nearly inedible.

Crispiness: 1.0

• A hint of crispiness in the skin but the entirely gummy meat completely ruins it.

Size & Quality: 2.5

•  Large size but inconsistent - some of the drums had cutoff bones and the flats were varying sizes.

Have you eaten at Mammoser's Tavern? Share your own experience in the comments below.

Return to the Buffalo Wing Bible final standings