Duff's Famous Wings (Original - Sheridan Dr)

Unbeatable uniformity in flavor and sauciness! 

Final Overall Score: 4.9 

Restaurant: 5.0 

• The Duff's original location reeks of Buffalo... in the best way possible! Duff's on Sheridan Dr has that slightly divey yet cozy feel - wood clad bar and all. A great atmosphere in which to experience some of the very best wings that Buffalo has to offer.

Taste: 5.0 

• Impeccable. Just impeccable. Crispy, saucy, juicy, and spicy with thick bleu cheese and crunchy celery sticks. The overall taste could not be more perfected.

Sauce: 5.0 

• A perfect medium Buffalo sauce - perhaps a smidge on the hot side, but oh so good. Part of the reason Duff's sauce is seen as a bit hotter than others is due to the large quantity of sauce they use. The more sauce, the hotter the wings seem. We believe there is no such thing as "too much sauce" on such a great wing, especially when the sauce is so delicious and well balanced.

Crispiness: 5.0 

• Again, perfection. Crispy with an audible crunch on the outside, thoroughly cooked, juice meat on the inside.

Size & Quality: 4.5 

• While it's known that Duff's goes through a pretty rigorous quality control process for their wings, a couple of our wings were quite a bit larger and some smaller. Although this is minor, we must hold every wing to the same standard and some points were deducted for this.

Have you eaten at Duff's Famous Wings in Amherst, NY? Share your experience in the comments below.

Return to the Buffalo Wing Bible Final Standings